Design Audit
Audit before sign-off. Findings first. Failures beat praise.
Required Gates
-
Hierarchy + grouping
- Clear first/second/third look targets.
- Spacing, type, contrast, and enclosure point to the same structure.
- No decorative cards/containers that invent false grouping.
-
Interaction + state coverage
- Core actions are obvious.
- Default, hover, focus, active, disabled, loading, empty, error, and success states are covered where relevant.
- High-frequency actions feel immediate; destructive actions use safer commit timing.
-
Responsive + ergonomic behavior
- Mobile layout collapses cleanly; no horizontal spill.
- Tap targets meet platform minimums.
- Hover-only behavior never gates functionality.
-
Accessibility + semantics
- Focus visible.
- Contrast valid for text and controls.
- Semantic order matches visual hierarchy.
- Reduced motion and keyboard use are handled.
-
Motion + continuity
- Motion explains change, preserves source/destination continuity, and stays interruptible.
- Novelty budget matches interaction frequency.
-
Identity + anti-generic quality
- Clear aesthetic point of view.
- No template fingerprints: default gradients, equal-card triplets, untouched library styling, decorative metrics, empty “AI-polish”.
- One memorable differentiator is present without harming usability.
-
First-screen litmus checks
- Brand or product is unmistakable in the first screen when applicable.
- One strong visual anchor exists.
- Headlines alone reveal the page narrative.
- Each section has one job.
- Cards are necessary, not habit.
- Motion improves hierarchy or atmosphere.
- The design still works if decorative shadows are removed.
-
Copy-mode correctness
- Marketing pages: promise, proof, convert.
- Product UI: orient, status, act.
- Fail if operational UI uses homepage-style filler or if marketing pages read like unlabeled back-office tooling.
Severity Order
- Accessibility blockers
- Interaction correctness
- Performance / responsiveness
- Layout / hierarchy
- Typography / color system
- Motion polish
- Cosmetic polish
Output Contract
- For reviews: findings only, ordered by severity, with concrete remediation.
- For implementation sign-off: state
passorfail, then list blockers and residual risks. - If no issues: say so explicitly and name remaining verification gaps.
Common Failure Patterns
- Generic SaaS card grid as first impression
- Beautiful hero image with weak brand presence
- Strong headline with no clear action
- Busy imagery behind text
- Repeated sections with the same mood statement
- App UI built from stacked cards instead of layout
Related Skills
design: establish direction before implementationdesign-interaction-motion-craft: motion and gesture reasoning