SPINE Framework
Critical rules
- Substance first: no insight, no article. Point outranks polish.
- SPINE is an evaluation lens — never use S/P/I/N/E as article headings; use information-carrying titles.
- Prove claims with running code or cited trusted sources. Never fabricate output or stats.
- Admit limits (Nuance). Land the plane (Exit) with insight + callback — not a recap or fluff ending.
- Before drafting or scoring, read references/elements.md.
Workflow
- State the one-sentence Point (no "how"). If empty, stop — no article yet.
- Draft Stakes in the first 30 seconds (who, felt problem, what they'll do, scope).
- Build Illustration that actually proves the Point; run every code sample.
- Add Nuance: ≥2 failure modes, costs, when NOT to use.
- Write Exit: restate insight, when to use, one takeaway, opening callback.
- Pass Voice and Clean last. Run the pre-flight in references/scoring.md and score.
Resources
- references/elements.md — Stakes/Point/Illustration/Nuance/Exit/Voice/Clean detail. Read when writing or reviewing.
- references/scoring.md — pre-flight checklist and score bands. Read before publishing.
Validation
- [ ] One-sentence insight in first 20%; repeated at end
- [ ] Reader can decide relevance in ~20 seconds
- [ ] All code run; claims sourced; no fabricated output
- [ ] Failure modes and when-not-to-use present
- [ ] Exit restates insight with callback; no fluff ending
- [ ] No SPINE-letter headings; pre-flight checklist passed
Constraints
- Not for README/API reference (
documentation-standards) or voice-preserving line edits alone (structured-writing). - Related:
documentation-standards,structured-writing,concise-output.